I should know better by now, having served as one of the midwives for almost 100 Twist patterns, than to second guess Fiona Ellis. I've spent my whole life second guessing and recalculating patterns, and I will continue to do so when I'm modifying, but I should trust Fiona and Sandi Rosner (the Twist technical editor) to write a pattern that actually delivers the sweater as it is pictured.
I finished the body pieces for Paula when I decided that I wanted to have the turtleneck maybe be a little more generous than as written. Plus, the finished opening looked huge, and I couldn't imagine picking so few stitches as the pattern suggested to get this result, so I used the pickup numbers for the next size up.
I was insecure about the collar while knitting it because of the stockinette portion which I feared wouldn't support the cable, and I worried I would have to rip the whole thing out eventually because it was doomed to collapse under its own weight. So I added extra cabling rows to make up for that, and lengthened the chart so I would have more collar to cover the joining row, just because. When I cast off this morning, it looked like this.
Looks fine, doesn't it? However, it sits poorly, and the edge of the collar curls up because (get this) it's. too. long. Everything I feared about the collar was all for naught, and if I had just trusted Fiona and Sandi in the first place and knit it as I was told, I would be wearing the sweater by now.
So I'm ripping. And next time, I'll listen.






